Skip to Content

Documentation

Electric BLDC Motors vs Thermal and Hydraulic: Strengths and Constraints for Agriculture*

Technological innovation in the agricultural sector has propelled brushless direct current (BLDC) motors as a serious alternative to traditional thermal and hydraulic engines. Efficient, precise, and environmentally friendly, these motors are transforming the way agricultural machinery operates. This article compares BLDC motors with their thermal and hydraulic counterparts, highlighting their advantages and disadvantages.

1. Electric BLDC Motors vs Thermal Engines

Advantages of BLDC Motors

  • High energy efficiency: BLDC motors consume less energy for the same work, reducing costs and environmental impact.

  • Instant start: Torque is available from the start, even at low speed, improving the responsiveness and precision of the machinery.

  • Zero local emissions: No combustion means no pollution at the work site.

  • Reduced noise: Quiet operation increases operator comfort and reduces fatigue.

  • Limited maintenance: The absence of brushes and wear-prone parts reduces maintenance needs.

Points to Consider

  • Battery-dependent autonomy: Performance and usage duration are limited by battery capacity.

  • Electronic management required: The complexity of control systems increases, which may require additional skills for maintenance.

2. Electric BLDC Motors vs Hydraulic Engines

Advantages of BLDC Motors

  • Often superior efficiency: BLDCs convert electrical energy into motion with fewer losses than a hydraulic system.

  • Precision control: They allow very fine control of speed and torque, crucial for modern agricultural applications.

  • Cleanliness: No hydraulic fluid, making it safer and cleaner for the work environment.

Points to Consider

  • Heat sensitivity: High instantaneous torque can cause overheating if thermal management is not optimal.

  • Sealing to be maintained: In dusty or humid environments, it is essential to properly protect the motor.

3. Additional Advantages of BLDC Motors

In addition to their specific advantages over thermal and hydraulic engines, BLDC motors offer additional features:

  • Very fine control: Ability to precisely manage speed, torque, acceleration ramps, and operating limits.

  • Integrated telemetry: Real-time measurement of current, temperature, and speed, facilitating performance monitoring and analysis.

  • Simplified robotisation: Collected data allows for effective automation and supervision of agricultural operations.

Conclusion

BLDC electric motors represent a future solution for modern agriculture. Their energy efficiency, low environmental impact, reduced maintenance, and precise control make them a serious alternative to thermal and hydraulic engines.

Certainly, challenges remain, particularly in terms of autonomy and electronic complexity, but the benefits of BLDC motors — reliability, precision, durability — make them a preferred choice for a more sustainable and connected agriculture.


*: The technical information presented in this article is provided for guidance only. It does not replace the official manuals of the manufacturers. Before any installation, handling, or use, please consult the product documentation and adhere to safety instructions. The Torque.works site cannot be held responsible for inappropriate use or incorrect interpretation of the information provided.